Willow vs elvie reddit. New comments cannot be posted.

Willow vs elvie reddit. I get so many mixed message, one person will say why willows are better because they do xyz compared to elvie and then another comment says the exact opposite. I’ve tried both during late-night feeds, in the car, and while making school lunches—so I know what works in real life. You can get a second hand one for half price. But if you get the Elvie from Costco, you can actually return it. Elvie? So my insurance now covers 70-100% of wearable pumps, which is great. I was debating between the Willow go and Elvie for a long time and ultimately got the Elvie because I wanted to use the app to see how much I had pumped, but honestly this feature sucks and barely works lol. Since I have those two as backups, I’m really excited to give one of these wearable pumps a go! Oct 2, 2025 · Lighter, sleeker and quieter than the Willow Go, the Elvie is the most discreet wearable pump on the market. Do you guys recommend the Willow or elvie for my nip size. I believe one has a 28 and one does 27. I am intrigued but the no return policy on a brand new pump scares me a bit when you are shelling out 300 bucks for a new product. Thanks! Share Sort by: Best Open comment sort options Add a I've heard the willow/elvie pumps can be a bit finicky. Jul 20, 2022 · Willow vs. Also not opposed to the Elvie Stride if any beta testers or new users have feedback! Feb 6, 2023 · UPDATED!! Wearable Breast Pump Comparison for all my Elastigirls: Elvie vs Momcozy vs Willow Go February 6, 2023 by realgraceshines Leave a Comment “The future is now. Has anyone hear tried both and have comparisons to offer? Anyone who uses the willow experience problems with it? Any tips from Elvie users? Locked post. Plus Willow makes you buy their special brand specific milk saving bags whereas you can use any bages with Elvie. I like that the elvie is quieter and can hold more, but also like that the willow can be used in any position and reportedly has stronger suction. Please note of We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Elvie replaced my unit after a battery issue. The provider I am considering ordering from shared a list of pumps covered with my insurance as well as partially covered pumps with an additional fee. Parenting writer Sara Gaynes Levy tested the Go and seven other wearable breast pumps to find the best options for everyone, including those pumping I know this has been asked before…but I want your fresh take! What is, in your opinion and experience, the best wearable pump out there? Elvie, willow, momcozy, etc? Additionally, the willow is easier to clean, had fewer pieces, and leaks less. There’s also multiple elvie and willow buy/sell/trade groups on Facebook. These are our top picks of 2025. I fully intended to purchase Elvie pumps again with this baby. Right now I have the Medela Pump in Style and I’m already so sick of being tethered to one spot while I pump every 3 hours. The tubes always got in the way and the power part is heavy so you have to make sure you wear sturdy pants or attach it to your bra. I used my momcozy for the month and I’m not a fan. I whole heartedly believe that both the Stride and Go should be the leading products for both Willow & Elvie. littlepinkhen Elvie vs Willow Go pump? Recommendations I am going to have my second baby when my first will be 17 months, and I am anticipating needing to use a hands free breast pump more than I did for my first kid. 0 vs Elvie I’m a PA student in my clinical year and went back from maternity leave in January. Not sure if that one size makes a difference. I just don’t know which to get so I thought I’d turn to my fellow Redditors. The Willow 3. comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment peony I don’t have the Willow go, but I like my Elvie Stride. 5 ounces. The go is quiet you can barely hear it. I was pretty convinced that these pumps would have milk overflowing my house. I ended up buying the Willow first based on all the reviews and had it for a couple of months before buying the Elvie. Sep 28, 2023 · Elvie Pump Freemie Liberty Wearable Breast Pump System Willow Generation 3 Is Willow Or Elvie Better? The Willow Pump is the most discreet of these three, but it only has a 4oz collection cup. And I still feel confident in my choice of Elvie vs the original Willow pumps based on reviews. Has anyone tried all of them or maybe 1 or 2 of them? Any Has anyone used the Elvie Stride or Willow pumps that could offer a comparision to the Spectra? I love the idea of portable and hands-free, though I'm fortunate enough to be working from home, so if the Spectra is still the best, please let me know! Also open to other suggestions. I just heard about the babybuddah/legendairy cups combo and that looks interesting and about half the price. Really? Like it’s $500 and you can’t include 2 chargers? The Elvie does its job for what its worth but performance wise there are better breast pumps in todays market that have a seamless assemble and out perform the Elvie and Willow. I don't think I can justify the Willow 3. For my personal use, I bought Elvies though, because they were highly recommended by a coworker and because the willows had a LOT of reports in reviews about repeat errors/malfunctions with the Willow. I think if you’re deciding between Elvie and Willow, definitely go with Elvie. Reply reply Rebecca_Davenport • Some folks say that that the Willow is much more reliable. Just had my 2nd baby and going back to work in August - debating getting a Willow because my least favorite part about the Elvie was cleaning so many parts, and pumping into bottles that I immediately dumped into plastic bags. Feb 27, 2024 · The Bump recruited two nursing moms to help us out hammer out the pros and cons of each product—one to test the Elvie Pump and one to try out the Willow Go. I’ve noticed my supply decline and when I use my spectra i produce an additional 2-3oz more. Despite essentially having 2 pumps and thus, needing 2 chargers, it only comes with 1 charger. It legit caused sharp pains in my breast. For the wearable pump, need it to have good suction and can be used discreetly. So I'm doing some research on the Willow Go and the Elvie Stride. What are your thoughts? I had some Momcozy s9 pros that I loved but they were too loud for an office Elvie stride vs Willow Go Recommendations for either one? They are both covered by my insurance. It's a good choice if you’ll frequently be pumping in public or an office setting and hope to do so without most people noticing. Wearable pump Recs Willow 3. See full list on bemytravelmuse. The Willow go is more heavy than the Elvie but if you get a good bra for the Willow it will be fine. Both pumps take getting used to i had to use then both multiple times for my supply to be the same as what i usually get from a wall pump, the willow also has a learning curve just based on your breast and shape you really have to position it well to make it work. It can be a little finicky about the parts being put together the right way, but I really only had an issue in the beginning when I was figuring it out. I know everyone is different, but those who have used either the Willow or Elvie- did you love it or hate it? Looking for some honest feedback! Thanks in advance :) comment sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment AutoModerator • Additional comment actions We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Based on some reviews it seems like I'll mostly be comparing pain points in things like the milk storage as you're pumping or the strength of the pump. 0 or an Elvie. Anyone have either of these options and can share their thoughts? Thanks in advance! Archived post. When you're pumping every 2/3 hours, 45 minutes is a LONG time. I also still have my previous pump (a Lansinoh) from my first baby, as well as a Medela portable pump, which I really liked. I have the Elvie and I really like it. Elvie is the ultimate question in the wearable pumping world. Just use pay pal buyer protection for payment to avoid scams and sterilize everything when you get it. The Elvie is slim and quiet. In my opinion both the Stride and Go are far easier to use than the original pumps offered 𝘢𝘯𝘥 less money. Both Strides had the same level of suction. But I see that the Willow Go pumps get great reviews. I feel like this is hard to answer. My nipples aren’t long enough for a newborn to latch. 0 or the original Elvie. Keep reading to see how these pumps stand up against each other. Willow vs Elvie (wireless pumps). But, Willow also nickel and dimes you. Any thoughts ? Sidenote, I work with the lactation I really like the willow with it having the 2 options for pumping (reusable containers or storage bags) but is it really leak proof? What was your opinion if you used either? I have not tried the Willow or Elvie, but I have been reasonably happy using a spectra s9 with the Legendairy wearable collection cups. But which is better? Check out this review! Elvie Original vs Willow Go?? Ok y'all I've been lurking on this sub for literal ages and I'm finally at the point where I want to splurge on a wearable pump, but they're not cheap, so I'm making it official so I can ask the question: Original Elvie or Willow Go? I tried a friend's Willow 3. My insurance covered $200 off of a pump, so I saved some money that way. I'd love to get this community's perspective on the more "mobile" pumps, like the Willow, Elvie, and Freemie. LM cups + BB on a good day, I see ~75-80%. For me, the Baby Buddha is the best portable pump, but the cups are a PITA to clean. They’ve both been out for a while now and I watched sooo many youtube videos before making my first purchase. I recommend getting a Baby Buddha or Pumpables pump and pairing it with Legendairy Milk or freemie cups before dropping a bunch of cash on Willow or Elvie. With reusable containers, range of motion is the same between the Willow Go and the Willow 3. Willow vs. I personally love the Spectra and how strong it is. Because they're so expensive, most people have ever only tried 1 or 2. Could even buy flanges for my spectra to make it lower profile. Elvie: Very close to "set and forget" - automatically switches from letdown to expression mode. I am looking for what will be the most efficient in being able to produce the most, quiet When I have the wearable available, I would still use spectra as my primary pump and the wearable as a secondary one, probably 3-4x a day. My Elvie is sitting on top of my fridge collecting dust - I was only ever able to get (at most) 50% of my normal output with them. ” At least that’s what I thought when I bought my Elvie pumps a couple weeks after Rigel was born. New comments cannot be posted. 5yrs ago for a colleague. 5-5oz, so I’m leaning towards the Elvie since Willow only holds 4oz. I pump 2-3x during my 8 hr shift. It's so comfortable, gentle but powerful suction, and easy to clean. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Some backstory- I am expecting baby #2 in March. Oct 26, 2022 · These pumps are Willow & Elvie’s “more affordable product options”. Does anyone have experience with these specific two pumps? My insurance will cover either. I was so stressed from trying to pump for 40+ mins and getting no more than 20ml. Any ideas?! I'm trying to decide between getting an elvie vs a willow 3 vs willow go, and I'm having trouble finding clear info about whether the fridge hack works with any of them. I want to say willow has a 250 hour life vs elvie 500 hour life. Willow? Hi all, I am going back to work and I am deciding if it’s worth it to purchase the Elvie or the Willow breast pump. Jun 11, 2025 · The best wearable breast pumps are comfortable, effective and portable. I want to buy one but such a big investment for something I’m not sure will work well and can’t be returned. Here is a comparison I made when I was pumping 1. com Aug 10, 2025 · In this Elvie Stride vs Willow Go guide, I’ll show you the real differences so you can pick the one that fits your lifestyle, budget, and comfort. We’ll evaluate for a tongue tie right away and I am fully aware of the signs of postpartum depression that I missed the first time. Jan 22, 2023 · Hands-free pumping is life-changing! But which is the best wearable breast pump - Elvie or Willow or Momcozy? Here is a comparison! I opted for the Elvie because you don't have to buy all the accessories separately and you do with the Willow. Compare that with Elvie which I have returned in the past (bought at Target) when it leaked . I see the Willow has complaints of leaking and the Stride is too gentle. Aug 4, 2022 · Though both Elvie and Willow are excellent options and comparable in many ways, there are some notable differences. comment sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment DylanDempsey18 • Jan 22, 2025 · Hi Mama! Looking for an Elvie pump review? You’re in the right place! As a breastfeeding and pumping mama to my second baby, I’m on a mission to review as many pumps as possible and spread the word about the pros and cons of them all. Freemie vs Elvie vs Willow? Hey all. There is a great comparison (of the Elvie and Willow) video by Mommy Shark on YouTube. Apr 14, 2025 · The best wearable breast pump is the Willow Go. I don’t have experience of the Willow but just wanted to urge you to take the good reviews of the Elvie with a pinch of salt! We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Jan 24, 2024 · We put two of the internet’s favorite cordless breast pumps to the test to see how they stack up in this Willow Go vs. I’m hoping this works much better and my milk production is higher the second time. The best thing about the elvie is it has an app where you can see how long you’ve been pumping for and track your output my insurance covered the Elvie stride plus which came with a great carry-on case in a freezer bag so I was able to take this pump to a bunch of activities and events! I have an Elvie stride and willow go. I am currently pumping and supplementing with formula due to low supply and struggles with latching. Freemie: Cheaper than the other two, and more customizable fit. With #1 I breastfed until he was 1 and I only pumped when absolutely necessary (ie at work). 5 parts to We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Anyone have any personal experience with willow and/or elvie pumps? The reviews are all across the board on both. I pretty much use Elvie’s exclusively now at home too just because they’re so portable and convenient instead of my motif Luna just because I don’t want to be trapped with giant bottles hanging off of me We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. I’m really liking it - it’s a game changer for being able to do stuff around the house. I had heard that the suction wasnt enough on portable pumps, but I figured I could make it work as I'm a natural oversupplier. We rated the Elvie Pump as the best bag-free wearable pump in a previous review, but the lights on the pump make it less discreet than the other pumps. I changed to a regular type pump and it’s a lot better, I’m getting triple that in 10 mins most times. On my list, I have the momcozy m5, elvie stride and genie advanced. Babe is 2. 0. However, they are really expensive, and I’m wondering if anyone has had any experience with the Elvie or the Willow? If so, what was your experience? Do you feel like they pulled as much milk as a traditional pump? Are they worth the cost? Which one is stronger/better? Is the Elvie really silent? Thanks! Archived post. Jun 22, 2022 · Willow Go and Elvie Stride are new versions of the wearable pumps from both companies. Jun 3, 2020 · A new mom reviews two smart breast pumps Can wearable models from Willow or Elvie rival a traditional system? Elvie Stride vs Willow Go Soon to be 2nd time mom- used the spectra s2 with my first. Jan 5, 2024 · Compare Willow Go & Elvie Stride breast pumps: design, portability & suction strength. Low leakage preferred. 0 offers the option of pumping with disposable bags or reusable containers. Also I found a website talking about Willow pumps and how they cause "tater tot" nipples which is the exact thing I'd like to avoid this time around as that is something that I Anyone have this yet?? I think it’s a new pump from Motif, their version of a willow/elvie. The Elvie didn’t have enough suction for me and couldn’t fully empty me the way my other pumps could. These worked great and weren’t a major problem. I’m very determined to make it work this time! I hVe the Elvie stride for confidence (main pump is a spectra s2). In hindsight I’d probably have gotten the Willow go! Posted by u/proteinbowl1991 - 1 vote and 1 comment I keep flip flopping between willow pumps and elvie pumps. For modern moms on the go. I wasn’t willing to compromise my milk supply for convenience, which sucks because the Elvie was SO convent. Currently 4 weeks pp have had mastisis 2 times and am wondering if the 1-2 times a day I use the elvies if that’s what causing the clogs. I just got an Elvie and I’m a 38F or larger…I was an xl busty while pregnant and probably xxl now. The willow go WOULD have been my so time favorite for comfort and milk production, however it was ultimately abandoned due to its many broad and frustrating issues. For the most part, he couldn’t even tell when I was pumping with my Elvie Willow only comes with one charger. I’ve had the Elvie Stride and the Willow Go. And we’ve made both of them our picks in a separate guide to wearable breast pumps. ETA: I also experienced leakage with the Elvie that ended up getting into the tubing and broke my machine because the milk got into it It seems like the biggest benefit of willow over Elvie is that it’s leak proof but that’s only with the bags which are expensive. This was all while I was a resident. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. I need something easy to clean and also that can properly drain me as I have an oversupply. This combo does not remove milk nearly as well as the spectra s1 or s2 and the regular flanges, but now that my supply is well-established I can use the wearable cups once or twice a day without issues. Aug 1, 2022 · Willow Go only allows pumping into containers, and you do need to limit bending and rapid movements while pumping to prevent milk spilling from the top of the pump. Nothing light. I love my motif Luna and could not choose between either of the above but still kind of want a hands free pump! We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Best hands free pump you’ve invested in? Help me out: ️ ️ ️ I am trying to decide between a Willow Go and an Elvie Stride. The first time I tried Willow, my husband asked “wtf is that”. The only downside of the Elvie is that you really can’t lean over or back The Elvie wasn’t nearly efficient enough to pump several times a day, so I ended up renting a hospital pump. . Elvie vs. Looking for some thoughts. I have found neither the St. The Willow is similar to the Spectra in the sense that it has sort of a vibrating stimulation and suction, and you're correct that the suction can be adjusted in both stimulation and expression modes. The willow you buy into the system, comes with one charging cable, one flange size, a small set of bags, also has a shorter pump life. Their storage bags are expensive. 5 weeks old. Elvie vs Willow Go Pump? I am going to have my second baby when my first will be 17 months, and I am anticipating needing to use a hands free breast pump more than I did for my first kid. I have a spectra S1, a willow go, an Elvie stride, a momcozy s12 pro, a momcozy M6, and a medela hand pump. Elvie vs Willow Has anyone tried either the Elvie or Willow pumps? If so, what has your experience been like? I’m interested in both, but I’m having trouble making a decision based on the limited reviews I can find. Until willow. I need good suction. I use the spectra size 28 flange. Mar 31, 2025 · As with the Elvie Pump and the Willow Go, with the Momcozy S9 Pro pump, the buttons on the top allow you to control modes and suction, or to turn the pump on or off. If second hand grosses you out there’s occasional brand new, still wrapped in plastic kits available for less than retail. Elvie vs Willow vs Zomee wearables. I've tried to Google comparisons and it's always the willow go and not the 3. Both are great, but is one better? Read this honest review! I only used a Willow once, borrowed from a friend to test out the concept of the in-bra pumps. 0 vs Elvie Hello! I am an RN and am looking for any advice on choosing a Willow 3. I went with elvie over willow after reading and watching a ton of reviews. This will be my on the go pump but would love to use it in the office. I had Elvie stride and had very minimal output, same with even my spectra my first time around. It comes in at around 32 decibels, the quietest pump on our best-of list. I’m an under supplier. Pregnant with my second kiddo and wanting something more modern but also worried about an Elvie/Willow not having as much suction power as the more traditional pumps. Share Sort by: New Open comment sort options Best Top New Controversial Old Q&A Add a Comment Stelri I had the Elvie and I absolutely hated it, just didn’t work for me. Read on for more about each of these wearable smart pumps, plus pros and cons to consider as you shop. So I'm looking into an electric hands free pump and can't decide between the elvie and willow products. Willow is very large, loud, and noticeable. Locked post. For willow you can pump bending over or in bed bc of the bags. Been debating on getting a mom cozy. I have 2 pumps already, Spectra and Baby Buddha, but I’d prefer a wearable breast pump, so I can work while pumping and go home earlier. But, I have decided to treat myself to either the Willow or the Elvie to make pumping easier in general. If you want reusable containers to pump into that’ll cost you an extra $50. 0 and HATED it. Wearable recommendations? Momcozy M5 vs Willow Go (or other?) I am 12wpp and have been exclusively pumping since 8wpp, and am really wanting to get a wearable option for out in public. I used a Spectra almost every day at work for a year, and it was a workhorse but of course clunky. Hi mamas! Currently choosing between the elvie and willow breast pump and I can’t for the life of me make a decision. Anyone have input on either of these or any other hands free pumps?? I think it will be available 7/30. I heard the Willow has better suction if that’s a concern for you. I have a bunch of wedding to go to/be in and dresses that work with regular flanges are tough. Absolute game changer. The parts are easier to clean and you don’t have to buy the special bags to go inside the pump. Any feedback you have is welcome! Oct 3, 2025 · The Best Wearable Breast Pumps We Used During Work Calls, Chores, and Caring for Kids These hands-free devices give you the freedom to multitask while pumping that liquid gold. ELVIE STRIDE VS WILLOW So sorry if these two questions have been asked already — but I read a few threaded and didn’t find what I wanted/needed. The found a new, sealed in box Elvie for $331 on eBay. After doing my review of the Willow, it only made sense to do an Elvie pump review too! It’s the other popular, wearable pump on the market, and I had to That being said, I’d like for things to go differently the next time around. Would like a portable option to use along side with this next journey! Any advice/recommendations? I did not have a good support system or knowledge so my first pumping journey only lasted like a month. Stronger suction isn't always better, it's consistency that gets things going. Expect to receive it in June (they are currently on backorder). With my spectra I get 3-4 ounces per session (every 2-3 hrs) with elvies I get tops 1. Mar 23, 2023 · If you're trying to decide between the Elvie pump and the Willow pump, this will help you choose which one is best for you Never tried the Elvie, but I love the Willow Go. Willow 3. For those of you who have used them what are… You likely have a wealth of knowledge… opinions on willow go vs willow vs elvie double vs elvie stride? trueI’m pregnant with my second and am definitely doing a wearable pump this time. These things were all relatively minor complaints, to be clear. Share Sort by: Best Open comment sort options Best Top New Controversial Old Q&A Add a Comment financequestionsacct • Anyone done this or have reviews on either the Willow or Elvie? My max yield on my hero boob is about 4. Momcozy M5 throwdown. The technology just isn't there yet in my opinion. Elvie Stride - less bulky than the Willow Go but harder to position correctly on the nipples. Anybody tried both to compare output? Any strong recommendations for/against an Elvie or Willow? Elvie vs Willow Pump? Hey everyone, FTM and still pregnant (35w), but I’ve been looking into getting a breast pump for those times I can’t breastfeed or just need to pump. Which have you found is the best on this list? I would love to hear the pros and cons of the one (s) you have used based on your personal experience. Keep in mind for either of these breast pumps you need to wear a larger bra that enables room for your breast pump to be inserted into. Mar 31, 2025 · We’ve concluded that the best in this category are the Elvie Pump and the more budget-friendly Willow Go. I need it for pumping at working, and the sink options at my job are nasssssty, so I'm going to have to rely on keeping the parts in a cooler in between uses. 0 is so far working much better for me than the Elvie OG. 47r iy6e s3h7a 35v tc 3sug zrh 34n7eo3h y1nd a9

Any unauthorized reproduction of articles, photographs, charts, etc. published on MANTANWEB is prohibited. Copyright belongs to MANTAN or its information providers.